DealScan.devUsed value estimate
2021 Tesla Model Y value
By the DealScan team · Updated 2026-07-11
Quick answer
A 2021 Tesla Model Y in good condition with average mileage (about 62,500 miles) is worth roughly $18,400 in a private-party sale — a fair range of $16,950 to $19,850, or about $21,150 at a dealer. Note: 2021 is a flagged year for this model (2020–2021 (sight unseen)) — Early build quality: panel gaps, paint, rattles. Nothing dangerous, but never buy one without an in-person inspection. Expect to pay at the lower end and budget for that risk.
Estimated value by mileage
Good condition, clean title. Mileage is the biggest single factor at this age.
| Mileage | Miles | Fair value | Private party |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lower mileage | 42,500 | $20,150 | $18,550–$21,750 |
| Average mileage | 62,500 | $18,400 | $16,950–$19,850 |
| Higher mileage | 85,000 | $16,400 | $15,100–$17,700 |
Is 2021 a good year to buy?
2021 is a flagged year (2020–2021 (sight unseen)): Early build quality: panel gaps, paint, rattles. Nothing dangerous, but never buy one without an in-person inspection.
See all Tesla Model Y years to avoidWhat to check before you pay
- 2020–2021: panel alignment, paint defects, and trim rattles; inspect in person and in daylight
- 2021–2022: heat pump and related valve failures in cold climates, addressed through service campaigns; check the service history for heat pump work
- Early builds: front suspension noise complaints; listen over broken pavement
Found a 2021 Model Y listing?
Paste the ad into the analyzer and DealScan scores the deal against this value, flags the risks above when they apply, and lists what to ask the seller.
Check a listing free