Used value estimate
2016 Subaru Forester value
By Hari Vinayak · Updated 2026-06-12
Quick answer
A 2016 Subaru Forester in good condition with average mileage (about 125,000 miles) is worth roughly $9,550 in a private-party sale — a fair range of $8,800 to $10,300, or about $11,000 at a dealer. Note: 2016 is a flagged year for this model (2014–2016) — Oil-consumption engine plus the early CVT in one package — the highest-risk Forester combination. Expect to pay at the lower end and budget for that risk.
Estimated value by mileage
Good condition, clean title. Mileage is the biggest single factor at this age.
| Mileage | Miles | Fair value | Private party |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lower mileage | 85,000 | $11,350 | $10,450–$12,250 |
| Average mileage | 125,000 | $9,550 | $8,800–$10,300 |
| Higher mileage | 170,000 | $7,450 | $6,850–$8,050 |
Is 2016 a good year to buy?
2016 is a flagged year (2014–2016): Oil-consumption engine plus the early CVT in one package — the highest-risk Forester combination.
See all Subaru Forester years to avoidWhat to check before you pay
- 2011–2015: FB25 oil consumption — check the dipstick now and ask how often oil is added between changes
- 2014–2018: CVT failures led Subaru to extend coverage to 100,000 miles — confirm whether the CVT was serviced or replaced
- 2019+: windshield stress cracking and parasitic battery drain complaints — ask about replacements
Found a 2016 Forester listing?
Paste the ad into the analyzer and Dealscan scores the deal against this value, flags the risks above when they apply, and lists what to ask the seller.
Check a listing free